[talk] Why was BTS Jin the only one left out of the ending credits? Album, Song Camp, Silver Spoon

We will summarize everything at once, from why BTS's Jin was excluded from the credits on the 5th studio album to behind-the-scenes stories from song camp and the "silver spoon" controversy. Easily find out why this became a controversy among fans and what the actual facts are.

 

1. Why was BTS Jin left out of the album credits?

 

With the recent release of BTS's 5th studio album 'ARIRANG', the most talked-about aspect was the fact that Jin's name was not listed in the composition and lyrics credits.

 

To start with the conclusion,
It is more accurate to view this as an issue regarding the timing of participation in the work rather than an intentional exclusion.

It is known that Jin was unable to participate in the song camp on time due to his solo overseas tour schedule at the time, and by the time he joined later, the work on the major songs was already largely complete.
Therefore, it appears that his name was naturally not listed in the lyric and composition credits.

2. What is Song Camp? Why is it important?

This album work was done in the US It was centered around the song camp held in LA.
A song camp is a working method where multiple composers and artists gather to intensively create songs over a short period of time.

In other words, whether you participated during this period directly affects the song credits.

Because Jin could not be with us during this key work period,
Consequently, it is most natural to understand it as a structure that is missing from the credit.

3. The Actual Situation as Seen Through the Members' Remarks

 

The atmosphere becomes clearer when you look at the members' remarks.

RM stated, “It is a shame that we could have spent more time together if the tour had ended just a little sooner,” and
V explained, “I wasn’t feeling well. Because I’ve been on tour continuously.”
Jimin said, “The album was able to be released because you protected the team.”

To summarize this
It is more accurate to view this as a situation where participation was limited due to schedule and physical condition, rather than as exclusion.

4. But why did the controversy escalate?

In fact, this issue is closer to a controversy fueled by emotion rather than facts.

In some videos
The interpretation that Jin's expression looked disappointed
As opinions emerged that the members' way of speaking was not sufficiently considerate

“Why didn’t you apologize?”
The attitude is disappointing

It spread with the same reaction.

on the other way
Since the video is edited, the full context cannot be understood.
It could be the team's natural atmosphere.

There is also an opinion that...

5. Is the rumor about BTS's Jin being born with a silver spoon true?

Along with this, the theory of being born with a silver spoon has resurfaced.

To summarize

There is a mention that his father is a CEO running a business in Germany, and
I had a lot of experience traveling abroad and sports when I was young,
It is generally true that I grew up in an affluent environment.

 

but

The fact that it was a short-term English camp, not studying abroad,
The story that the family has declined lacks clear evidence, given that

Rather than being what is commonly referred to as a "chaebol-level silver spoon,"
The most realistic interpretation is to view them as upper middle class or affluent families.

Q&A

 

Q1. Did Jin really not participate in the album production at all?
A. It appears that while they were not entirely uninvolved, they joined the core songwriting and lyric-writing stages late, which is why their name was not listed in the credits.

 

Q2. Did the members intentionally exclude them?
A. Based on the information disclosed so far, there is no indication of intentional exclusion, and it is generally viewed as a scheduling issue.

 

Q3. Is Jin born with a silver spoon?
A. While it is true that he grew up in an affluent environment, it is difficult to definitively categorize him as a "silver spoon" on the level of a chaebol; many view him as being at the upper-middle-class level.

 

Q4. Why has the controversy grown so large?
A. The impact was amplified within the community as the facial expressions and remarks in the video were interpreted emotionally.

 

Check real-time popular posts

 

A Complete Guide to Starbucks KBO Collaboration Goods Sales Schedule and Types! (+Why Lotte and LG Are Missing)

A Complete Guide to the Dreamy Pâtissière Collaboration Cafe: Reservation Methods, Schedule, Goods, and Special Benefits!

Perfect Guide to BTS 'Swim' Lyrics, Interpretation, Translation, and Pronunciation! FT. Gwanghwamun Concert