BTS Jin Getting Photoshopped All Alone?! BTS, HYBE (+Song Camp Controversy)

Recently, the controversy surrounding BTS Jin's Photoshopping is spreading rapidly online.

The BTS Jin Photoshop controversy, in particular, has intensified as issues with official images overlapped with song camp and credit controversies.

The situation appears to be spreading further. Let me summarize the key points of why this controversy has escalated.

1. Only BTS Jin Photoshopped? Official Photo Controversy

The beginning of the recent BTS Jin Photoshop controversy is an official HYBE image.
It is claimed that in the released photos, editing was observed that makes it appear as though Jin's height has been uniquely reduced.

RM maintains natural proportions
Jinman relatively reduced
Proportions that appear to be around 173cm

(The top photo is the official one, and the bottom photo is from the Ministry of Culture.)

Especially considering that the image in question is official content
The controversy surrounding BTS Jin's Photoshop work has spread, extending beyond simple editing to a debate over intent.

2. The reason it is intertwined with the Song Camp controversy

The biggest reason the recent controversy regarding BTS Jin's Photoshop use has escalated is the song camp issue that recently surfaced.

Jin absent from initial work due to solo tour schedule
Song camp-centered production structure
Natural decrease in participation

As a result of this, among fans
“Isn’t Jin constantly being left out of key processes?”, “It’s too much considering we toured for the fans”

...was in a state where awareness had been formed.

3. Even credit exclusion… Controversy escalates

On top of this, there was also an issue with the album credits. Only Jin was excluded from the songwriting and composition credits.

It became difficult to reflect this due to joining later, and a subtle atmosphere formed while discussing this during a live broadcast.

In particular, as the members' remarks and Jin's facial expressions became a hot topic, the issue escalated from a simple scheduling problem into an emotional controversy.

Ultimately, the controversy surrounding BTS Jin's Photoshop is being interpreted as the result of multiple incidents overlapping, rather than just a single photo.

4. Fan Reaction, Simple Mistake vs. Repeated Pattern

Current reactions are sharply divided.

✔ Understanding Position

The schedule issue is realistic
Difficulty balancing tours and albums

✔ Raising an issue

It's strange that Photoshop is also involved.
Isn't it a repetitive structure?

In particular, suspicions have grown even larger as the BTS Jin Photoshop issue becomes linked to existing controversies.

FAQ

Q1. Is the BTS Jin Photoshop controversy true?
The controversy began with the opinion that the proportions of Jinman looked different in the official image.

Q2. Why did the controversy escalate?
It expanded as it overlapped with song camp and credit issues.

Q3. Did Jin not participate in the album?
It is known that although he joined in the later stages, he had difficulty participating in the initial work.

Q4. Do you have an official statement?
As of now, there is no separate official statement.