인기 게시판 TOP 50
[All]
SS501's Heo Young-saeng: Why Did a 16-Year Fan Finally Declare They're Unfollowing? The Fan Deception Controversy
2026.11.06 11:21
A controversy over fan deception has erupted after a 16-year fan of SS501's Heo Young-saeng announced she was leaving the fandom following the birthday cafe event. We have summarized the problematic remarks, the rebuttal from the fan who uploaded the video from the scene, and even the case of T.O.P.
These days, there really isn't a single quiet day in the 2nd generation idol fandoms 😭
The news about the closure of a top fan site hasn't even died down yet, but now it is said that a long-time fan of SS501's Heo Young-saeng has stopped their fan activities, leaving a short message that simply said "Close."
It is said that a fan who had been supporting them for a whopping 16 years since elementary school gave up because of a single birthday cafe.
Let me go through everything point by point: exactly what happened at the scene that day, and what the current situation is like now that counterarguments have emerged 👇
1. The decisive reason a 16-year fan left the fandom: Remarks made at the birthday cafe
The real reason for leaving the fandom wasn't 'because they didn't come to the birthday cafe,' but a single remark made right there on the spot 💡
A, the operator of the fan page, posted on social media on November 5 to announce the end of their fan activities.
According to A's claim, Heo Young-saeng said something to this effect at a gathering of fans.
Thankfully, they opened a birthday cafe for me. But they kept telling me to come...
Person A confessed that they were very embarrassed and felt wronged because they were worried that this remark would make them look like someone who had been persistently pestering for a visit.
My position is that I never spoke directly because I was worried about burdening them, and I only inquired indirectly via email.
He stated that the absence itself was not the problem, but he was disappointed by the attitude of those who responded to his attempt to support him by ignoring and embarrassing him.
I heard the post also contained a bitter sentence about how the 'urban legend' that opening a birthday cafe leads to quitting the fandom turned out to be true 😢
2. From preparing the birthday cafe to the day of the event, what happened
If you look at the sequence of events revealed by Mr. A in chronological order, it is as follows.
Heo Young-saeng's birthday cafe was held for the first time in about three years and was directly planned by A.
Around August, about three months before my birthday, I inquired with the agency about the possibility of visiting.
Received a response stating that "it is difficult to visit only a specific cafe because many fans are holding events in various locations."
Afterwards, A did not make any further requests, but other fans separately asked about visiting.
On November 2nd, an announcement was posted on Bubble stating that a separate cafe would be rented to meet fans on the birthday, the 3rd.
A closed the birthday cafe, which was scheduled to run until 6 PM, two hours early and moved to the event venue.
I inquired about displaying printed materials for the birthday cafe on-site, but was refused.
Instead, they asked for the fans' understanding and handed out cup holders, and it is said that almost all the fans put them on the drinks.
A said that it was puzzling that a new venue was rented, considering A must have known that a place for fans to gather had already been arranged at their own expense on the same day.
The point is that there was ample room to coordinate in advance.
They also added that they prepared for a whopping six months, cutting back on sleep despite being busy with their main job, and earned absolutely no profit 🥲
At the end, he reportedly took a photo wearing an apron prepared by Heo Young-saeng, and concluded the post by saying thank you for being an idol for 16 years.
3. "I didn't say that": Fan who uploaded on-site video refutes
As soon as the post spread, the atmosphere completely turned upside down 🔥
Another fan who was at the scene that day stepped forward to refute the claim by uploading a video.
The counter-argument from the fan is as follows.
The atmosphere at the scene was not one of embarrassing anyone.
Heo Young-saeng also clearly expressed his gratitude for the birthday cafe being opened.
I did not use the expression 'because you kept telling me to come'.
It was interpreted to mean that they had heard about the birthday cafe through various fans or the company, and it is unclear whether the remark was aimed at a specific fan.
Heo Young-saeng was in Japan until the day before and came to meet fans after treating a hand injury, practicing, and attending a meeting.
They also mentioned the scene where they wore an apron and responded to fans' requests one by one, and asked viewers to look at the entire context of the video.
Ultimately, claims among fans are conflicting regarding what was actually said, and Heo Young-saeng's intention behind the remarks has not yet been confirmed.
4. The controversy over 2nd generation fandom leaving continues, extending all the way to T.O.P's 'ChoiSeungHyun.com'
The reason this incident became a bigger topic of conversation is that it overlapped with the case of T.O.P from Big Bang.
T.O.P's representative fan site, 'ChoiSeungHyun.com,' established in 2006, announced the termination of operations on October 9.
The management sharply criticized the agency, stating that it relied on the fan site for promotion, communication, and even practical support tasks, and urged them to "lay down their arrogance."
T.O.P personally posted an apology on social media about three weeks later, on November 1st.
However, on the following day, the 2nd, heated debate arose again after it was revealed that he had visited a birthday cafe prepared by fans with his publicly known girlfriend, Nana.
Regarding Top Gun, criticism that it was 'deceiving fans' and counterarguments that it was a natural move with his lover emerged simultaneously.
5. Online Reactions and Changed Fandom Culture
Netizens' reactions to the Heo Young-saeng case were clearly divided.
The opinion that it is understandable to feel disappointed considering the effort poured in for six months.
Criticism that it is not embarrassing in a public setting
Conversely, there is a cautious view that the actual remarks and the atmosphere at the scene must be verified first.
Many people say that both cases demonstrate that long-standing affection no longer leads to unconditional support. ✨
It means that mutual respect and sincere communication between stars and fans have become more important than one-sided devotion like in the past.
💡 Frequently Asked Questions (Q&A)
Q. What is the reason a 16-year fan of Heo Young-saeng declared they are leaving the fandom?
A. She stated that it was not because she did not attend the birthday cafe, but because she felt embarrassed by a remark to the effect that "you kept telling me to come" at a gathering of fans.
Q. Did Heo Young-saeng really say that?
A. Another fan who uploaded the video from the scene refuted the claim, stating that they did not use the expression in question and that the remark was not aimed at any specific fan. The intent behind the statement has not yet been confirmed.
Q. Why did Heo Young-saeng rent a cafe separately?
A. It was to meet fans in person on the day of the birthday, November 3rd, and the announcement was made via Bubble the day before, on the 2nd. No separate statement was released regarding the background of the venue rental.
Q. Why did the T.O.P fan site ChoiSeungHyun.com close down?
A. The agency announced the termination of operations on October 9, citing that they relied on the fan site for fan communication and support operations, and that disappointment had accumulated over a long period.
Go to Real-time Best Popular Posts 👇
Why Mark Releases New Song After Leaving NCT, Reactions Say "Isn't It Church Music?"
Did the Namdaemun scarf guy get married? Age, Instagram, recent status
169K people are talking about Entertainment industry issues right now
576K people are talking about Idol right now
276K people are talking about comeback right now
Comments1
Popular in Free Board
Ranked by comments, likes, and saves from the last 24 hours
Ranked by comments, likes, and saves from the last 7 days
Ranked by comments, likes, and saves from the last 30 days
- 01CommentsThat is such a touching story. Roy Kim had a great voice, but that participant's voice is also really good.940026.11.03
- 03CommentsIt’s so great that it’s being held all over the country! I hope many people go to see it.580026.11.02
- 01CommentsBata, you're such a romantic~ I'm jealous of Ji Ye-eun haha870026.10.29
- 02CommentsSo you're wearing a three-piece suit because you're playing a chaebol. If that's the character, it makes sense to endure the heat and wear it.1040026.10.29
- 03CommentsIt's been a while since Yook Sungjae had a fan meeting. He seems to be having fun with the fans.550026.11.04
- 01CommentsI look forward to seeing the trainees take on the challenge of pursuing their dreams again! I am rooting for them to achieve great results and debut this time!1630026.10.17
- 02CommentsI don't think it's quite right for me yet. I can't really trust things that have no substance.1320026.10.16
- 03CommentsSo they didn't deliver in plastic containers back then. I've never ordered sundaeguk, so I wouldn't know.1200026.10.16
- 04
- 05
Eric Nam photos from the October issue of Esquire[20]
860026.10.31
- 06
- 07
A sunset sung by a 2010-born... If...[20]
800026.10.30
- 08
- 09
Newly revealed GRID TRAINEE members for Idol to Die 2[17]
840026.10.30 - 10
A male idol concept that makes you go "OMG".jpg[18]
880026.10.29
- 04
The trainee who finally made it onto the official member list[22]
890026.11.03
- 05
Recently concluded masterpiece youth drama.jpg[21]
700026.11.03
- 06
- 07
Yunseo, who won three consecutive catches in the Canaricano game[22]
800026.10.29 - 08
- 09
- 10
- 04
- 05
Ryu Hye-young, who filmed her first horror movie.jpg[30]
1260026.10.16
- 06
Songs that will still be listened to in 2026, more than expected[30]
1020026.10.16
- 07
- 08
- 09
It's surprising to hear that Kim Jong-min is becoming a dad.[28]
940026.10.15 - 10
A cover stage by a female idol who is a perfect fit for every genre[27]
1170026.10.20
